|
What is distance mentoring anyway? Is it really mentoring?
How can anyone mentor someone in a different city? How can we
build trust without being face to face?
If you're like most mentoring leaders, or if you've been approached
to participate in a long-distance mentoring partnership yourself,
these questions must be answered.
Here's what we've learned about this fairly new (at least by this
name) phenomenon, which we believe is not only here to stay
but is a potentially powerful strategy for helping people
develop.
What Is It?
You'll hear and see the terms virtual mentoring, remote mentoring,
telementoring, distance mentoring as well as offshoots such
as eMentoring. They all mean the same thing: a mentoring
relationship in which two parties (or the members of a mentoring
group) are in different locations (areas of a large city,
cities, states/provinces, countries).
The participants rely almost exclusively on electronic tools
(e-mail, online meeting software and platforms, videoconferencing),
phones, voicemail, faxes, and mail. The parties may meet face
to face one or more times during their partnerships, but most
of the time they're apart.
Why Use It?
Studies of mentors, mentees, and mentoring programs indicate
that sometimes the most effective mentor or mentee (in
terms of skills, knowledge, attitudes, experiences, contacts)
is located elsewhere. Depending on what the mentee wants to develop,
mentor location is less important than these other factors.
For example, in Hewlett-Packard Company's highest level leadership
development programs, high potential/high performing mentees are
paired with people who can most help them excel. Those senior
managers and individual achievers are often on the other side
of the globe. Microsoft Corporation does the same in its innovative
companywide career mentoring initiative. For years, HP has also
had an outstanding e-mail based program for adult mentors and
youth. The Association of Research Librarians and the Center for
Health Leadership link mentor-mentee partnerships across states
and time zones.
Here are some more reasons to use distance mentoring.
- Many mentors travel extensively.
Even if mentors and mentees are located in the same location,
one or both may travel most of the time. Consequently, for
most of the time they must use distance mentoring strategies
in order to be successful.
-
The uniqueness of it lends focus.
Distance mentoring provides, for many, the ability to focus
more intently. Since time is typically limited and participants
want the time to count, meetings are planned in advance, agendas
are exchanged, and both "get down to business" rather
quickly. When partners are nearby, it can be easy to cancel,
get caught up in chatting, or drift away from planned goals.
-
Many shy participants find it easier to communicate.
Many partners find they can have deeper discussions when
they aren't face to face. As one mentee put it, "I
can say things on the phone or in e-mail that I might feel
a little funny saying to him in person."
-
New learning occurs.
Finally, being in different locations increases at least
two types of learning. Having to use the tools and strategies
helps participants get skilled at and comfortable with these
technologies, which are going to expand in all areas of personal
and professional lives).
It also acquaints participants with unfamiliar cultures and geographies.
Working with the Veterans Health Administration, The Mentoring
Group learned that one purpose of their distance mentoring is
to acquaint future leaders (the mentees) with practices and traditions
of different parts of the Administration and well as of the U.S.
They hope that the familiarity gained from working with the distance
mentors will make the upcoming leaders more culturally savvy and
willing to and even excited about being relocated elsewhere.
Is It Really Mentoring?
Yes, provided the mentor is going out of his/her way to use an
intentional mentoring process and set of mentoring skills
to help the mentee identify important life goals and build
competence to reach them. In addition, the mentee must receive
and use the assistance she/he is given.
A Critical First Step in Distance Mentoring
Before you or your organization attempt distance mentoring, check
your beliefs and feelings about this strategy. If you're stalling,
you may need to make a paradigm shift in your thoughts and emotions.
Choose to recognize it as a viable strategy, build enthusiasm
for it, and find ways to maximize its benefits and reduce its
disadvantages.
|